I personally loved the film though I had never read the books but now that I have read the books I just have the tiniest amount of anger sometimes in all the films when characters switch lines or roles or important characters are left out.
But its wonderful all the same

I don't think anyone could have made it better! with acting skills, I think everyone did fabulous with potraying their character
I must admit that at first I felt Liv Tyler did'nt really slip into her character well but then I realised she did, it was just that she was a bit of a hard character to potray and I commend Miranda Otto on her potrayel of Eowyn.
When I was reading the books and visualising A few actors really stood out as I visualised the characters from paper which were Eowyn- Miranda Otto, Pippin-Billy Boyd but the best I felt was Sean Astin in his role of Samwise Gamgee but everyone was stunning and The trilogy will remain a masterpiece for years to come!

I also love how Peter Jackson said that the film was only his "personal interpretation" but it angers me a little when people thik of PJ rather than Tolkien concerning the stories

anyway, thats what i thought.