The Age of the Ring (Lord of the Rings) Forum
Tolkien only Section => Books - LOTR & The Hobbit => Games => Topic started by: ::Paper-Clip:: on March 13, 2004, 04:48:04 PM
-
Okay, here goes.
Basically, in this game you have to come up with an event from either the LOTR movies or books, and say what if?
eg: What would happen if Sam had not gone with Frodo to Mordor?
The next person then answers and asks another question.
You can also make up events, say like: What would happen if Gollum had been a girl? and so forth.
Only one rule applys: The quessies must by Tolkien related ;D
So, I´ll begin:
What would happen if Merry & Pippin had not followed Frodo to Rivendell?
-
then isenguard would've remained because the ents wouldnt have gone to war, and also it wouldnt be as funny
what if the fellowship formed a folk band ??? ::)
-
THen the people of middle Earth would have gone mad because of Gandalf's scratchy singing. Or they would've become famous. Either way.....
What if Bilbo hadn't "adopted" Frodo?
-
Then he wouldnt have passed the ring onto him, and middle earth would have been destroyed.
What if Eowyn hadnt followed the men into battle?
-
Then Merry wouldn't have gone to the Pellenor Fields and wouldn't have met up wth Pippin and Gandalf and the Witch-King wouldn't have been destroyed so the Fell Beast would have had a tasty meal of Flesh of Theoden!!! ::)
What if... Aragorn decided he couldn't be arsed to go to battle again and didn't lead out the 'diversion' to the Black Gate? ::)
-
Then Frodo and Sam would never have made it through all the orcs, would have been caught and torured and Sauron would have gotten the ring.
What if, no one came to save Frodo when he was stabbed?
-
which time do you mean? ??? he was stabbed at least 3 times
-
Haha, oops, the first time, by the witch king.
-
lol, no worries ;D
then eventually he would've become a wraith and taken the ring to sauron and middle earth would be doomed
what if sam never decided to rescue frodo after he was stabbed by shelob and taken away by the orcs?
-
Then Frodo would have been killed, and Sam, trying to reach the Cracks of Doom to destroy the Ring would have been corrpted and all would fall......
what would happen if Gandalf had not been able to revive Pippin after his ordeal with the palantir?
-
Then they'd basically be screwed as they wouldn't know about the siege intended on Gondor and so on.
What if Spiderman was Gollum? (sorry for the lameo suggestion but that's all I've got in my head)
-
lmao then when he fell into the fires of mount doom he wouldnt have died and swung up and taken the ring away again
what if aragorn had thought 'oo, but i dont wanna be king!'
-
Then Gondor would have become run down, and all the great decisions our good 'ole Aragorn made would have been shot to bugger!
what would happen if Pippin never found Merry near that dead Mumakil?
-
then Aragorn would not have got to him in time and tragically would have died
what would have happened if the Easterlings rode giant snails instead of elephants
-
Then it would take a very long time for them to get anywhere... ::)
What if Middle Earth had an Ice Age in the middle of the War of the Ring?
-
what would have happened if the Easterlings rode giant snails instead of elephants
Oliphaunts!!! Oliphaunts!!! Or Mumakil... ::)
What if Middle Earth had an Ice Age in the middle of the War of the Ring?
Then everyone would get extremely cold, some people might freeze to death and Frodo and Sam would have needed to put the whole destroyig the Ring thing on hold for a while... ::) :P
What if... Frodo was actually a woolly mammoth? ???
-
Then he'd be awfully hot in Mount Doom! And I'm not sure an orc uniform would have disguised him ::)
What would happen if all the hobbits were female?
-
Then Merry and Pippin wouldn't be allowed to fight, and Frodo and Sam would be both weaker and, well, weaker.
What if the other two blue Wizards were on Sauron's side? :o
-
then they would have found the ring almost instantly and the world would be doomed
what if legolas was a dwarve?
-
DWARF! >:(
Then for all I care they could start arguing over who had the longest beard, or even better, Legolas can trip over it and fall into the chasm in Moria.
What if Robin Smallburrow ambushed Sam and took his place?
-
Then Frodo would be buggered, because Robin wouldn't be able to keep him safe etc.
what would happen if Sam never married Rose?
-
Then he wouldnt have any children, and he might not have become mayor, (i dont know about that bit)
What if Saruman hadnt turned evil?
-
then the fellowship would have a powerffull ally
what if frodo was killed by the troll?
-
Then someone else would have had to take the ring and the whole course of the journey would be different, and the quest probably would have failed.
What if Gandalf hadn't caught Sam in the bushes, listening at Bagend?
-
then frodo would have been killed by golum and eventually sauron would have the ring
what if biblo killed gandalf when he told him to give the ring away?
-
Then Bilbo would probably have been killed by the Black Riders and all Middle-Earth would be covered in darkness as Sauron would have regained the Ring and his power :'(
What if... Denethor never tried to burn himself and his son alive then throw himself off the top level of Minas Tirith (in the film!) but was still mad, just in a non-homicidal capacity :P
-
...uh.... well... Gandalf would hit him with his staff again :).
What if the Hobbits had not met Tom Bombadil?
-
They won't have got out of the forest.
What if, Sauron had attacked the Shire like he did MT?
-
then all of them would be dead because they have no armies
what if witch king switched sides?
-
Then Sauron would have lost his best weapon, and the witch king could kill all the orcses!
What if Deagol had killed Smeagol instead of the other way around?
-
then 'gollum' wouldnt have such an annoying voice
what if gandalf hadnt returned
-
Then frodo would never had got his mithril coat back :'(.
What would happen if all the nazgul didn't excist?
-
Then the trip would have been alot easier for the hobbits at the begginig, and Aragorn might not have gone with them, to prtoect them from the Nazgul, so he might not have become king! :o
What if the elves didnt leave middle earth?
-
When did that happen
I'm guessing about this answer so:
There would be elves in middle earth ;D.
What if the witch king had stolen Arwen from Aragorn just as he was about to kiss her and he droped a troll in her place and he kissed it?
-
lol, then everyone would have a really good laugh, and the witch king is such a stud he wouldnt need to steal her from him,
what if the hobbits were double the size of men?
-
Then Frodo and Sam would kill Shelob easily, they wouldn't fit into Orc disguises, they'd be found.. uh.. Merry and Pippin would have a great advantage in battle.. only they wouldn't have horses big enough.. ::) PLUS, Hobbiton would be HUGE ;D
the witch king is such a stud he wouldnt need to steal her from him
LMAO!!!!!! ;D
What if Elves weren't pretty?[/color]
-
May I just add that for the Merry and Pippin advantage in battle that they'd actually be able to keep up with the Men in the move.
Then they'd probably be uglier than Trolls.
What if the Sorting Hat showed up in Mt Doom and threw Frodo a axe to kill Gollum with? ;D
-
hehehe
then harry potter would have flown past on his broom stick and caught the ring when gollum died
what if rangers were evil?
-
Then Aragorn would have killed everyone in the fellowship.
What if you had been locked away? witch-king guy
-
then i would have found iteasy to escape cos im so cool :P
what if gandalf had in fact been black and evil?
-
Then that would suck because Minas Tirith would have fallen and the Fellowship probably would not have ever become......
What if Eowyn had stolen Aragorn from Arwen??
-
Arwen and Eowyn would have a fight over him
What if Faramir had been burnt with Denthor?
-
Then poor Eowyn would have remained single forever. . . :P
what would happen if Rosie went along with Sam and Frodo?
-
Then Sam'd be REALLY screwed in Mt Doom because he'd have to choose between Frodo and Rosie.
-
you need to ask a question aswell muryn
-
shoot sorry bout that, thought i did....
What if the Underhills made Frodo really stoned and made him feck up the quest?
-
Even though he already "fecked it up" by utting the Ring on about a billion times? :P
He'd "feck it up" even more and basically wear the Ring all the way to Mordor and go dancing down the Road singing loudly in the middle of the night so the Ringwraiths can find him nice and easily!!! ::)
What if... Gandalf and Elrond both had those little Digimon things and kept battling in the middle of the Council?
-
then no one would watch lotr because they'd rename it lord of the digimon
what if, the mumakil rode turtles instead of oliphonts
-
I thought Mumakil were Oliphants?
If the Haradrim rode turtles instead of Oliphants, then the Rohirrim would be able get theirselves together and slaughter all of the baddies before the turtles even finished munching the grass ;D
what would happen if Frodo didn't leave to Valinor?
-
Somthing would go wrong(where is valinor?)
What would hqappen if the king of the dead went to war with Gondor?
-
Gondor would be dead.... :-\
what happens if frodo was a wizard?
-
I meant if the king of the dead was on thier side.
Frodo would find it alot easier on his Quest.
What would happen if The Nazgul and Souron had a fight about Morgoth's orders that he gave to them?
-
I meant if the king of the dead was on thier side.
He was anyway, wasn't he?
Then there'd have been a big magical battle between them then Morgoth would have ended it by killed the lot of them.
What if.... Galadriel decided to be tight and didn't give any of the Fellowship gifts when they left Lorien?
-
JESUS!!!!!! I MEANT IF THE WITCH - KING WAS FIGHTING WITH GONDOR!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
What if Aragorn married Arwen and Eowyn?
-
Then Arwen and Eowyn would be fighting a lot!!
What happens if Frodo had ridden Treebeard to Mordor?
-
Aww! Tweebeard wuold have been bwurned by de stwupid fwirebawls!
(Just so you know, that's supposed to be baby talk)
What if... Aragorn died?
-
then sauron would still be defeated but gondor would be without a king and would have to rely on faramir to rule gondor
what if wearing the ring made you turn into sauron?
-
Then theree would be about 3 different Dark Lords walking around and they'd probably be constantly plotting eah other's demise and also all trying to conquer Middle-earth at the same time. Gandalf would have to work vey hard! :P
What if... Minas Tirith was actually a giant casino? ???
-
Then Pippin would become a large Gambler and would never ever ever leave.
What if it turned out that Hobbits smoke cannabis? (mind you, the stuff they used for the movies was close enough, and look at them!)
-
then they would all be very stoned and see talking trees :-\
what if the mumakil were good?
-
Mind you, they did in the books "Stop it! He''ll eat me if you don't!"
Then Gandalf'd have one all to himself and be picking off all the orcses and evil men one by one with his nice bright spells.
What if... Mobile Phones were around in ME? (oh bioy, that'll be fun!)
-
[color=445533]Then Gandalf could have text Frodo to save him from Saruman!
What if Sauron was a foot?[/color]
-
Then Mordor would've been a lot smellier and he'd have no way to see what was going on.
What if modern-day weapons were around in Middle Earth?
-
Actually, he wouldn't need a ring or anything, he'd just trample over all the land.
Then the good guys would have 38 callibre machine guns and the baddies would have have their nukes and stuff.
(Sorry, I've just watched Saving Private Ryan)
-
Inhidrim, you need to ask a What If question :)
-
(Sorry, I've just watched Saving Private Ryan)
i love that movie! also black hawk down ::)
What if Frodo had been a girl? (then Sam would'a had a tough time re-wording some of his lines ::) ;D)
-
then she would have been very lost without a kitchen for miles :-\ *waits for the sexism mail*
nah im only joking ::)
what if the ring was a fake?
-
Then we would've all known that Sauron is in touch with his inner child, and likes his toys ;D
What if Sting did'nt want to glow blue? ;)
-
Then Sam would have kicked it around till it became blue ("How do you dare not help my master?!")
What if Rosie had actually been in love with Frodo?
-
then sam will probably say 'its ok im in love with frodo too' :-\
what if sauron really wanted to use the ring for good?
-
Then the world would have been a better place and there would have been no evil at all .. therefore no deaths due to un nessecary couses!
What if the Vala would have kept Gandalf dead instead of bringing him back to life?
-
Then they would've had a hard time without the white wizard..and Frodo would'nt have gone across the sea :P
What if Shelob had eaten gollom? 8)
-
then the ring would have not been destroyed and shelob would have a stomache ache
what if frodo was chinese and didnt understand a thing anyone said
-
Frodo: Ching i-ng powa..egg-foo young...Fortune cookie always wrong... *dies laughing* ;D
What if Sauron needs Visene? (eye drops) :P ::)
-
Then he'd have to give Saruman a call with his daily routene ..
What if .. Sauron never had a tower?
-
then he would just be an eye on the floor and be very easy to attack
what if samwise had kept the ring
-
He would have probally buried it in a plantpot! LOL!
What if Galadriel had a secret walkie talkie with Elrond?
-
...."The world is changed...." *Keerrshh* "Over" ;D (LMAO)
What if Gandalf was a girl? ;)
-
then she would be very hairy and would look hilarious ;D
what if gollum was a fierce warrior?
-
then that beard would have looked WRONG
what if the fellowship rode bikes
-
beat you to it ;D
-
Oh my goodness Frodo and Sam would not stand a chance against him!
That was for Witchking's as he replied first ..
What if there was magic mushrooms in Middle-earth?
-
then merry and pippin would be especially stoned
what if sauron didnt need the ring to exist?
-
Then if he had any wit, he would wait until Frodo got to the Cracks of Doom and pretend he was really upset, then when Frodo destroyed the Ring, he could laugh and kill him :P *mwhahaha!*
what if Sam hadn't come across the lembas and gone back to Frodo?
-
lol, the there would be a really small wraith walking around :-\ scary
what if arwen had died?
-
Then Aragorn would be happier and have got to marry his real true love...Legolas!
What if Legolas's hair got messy?
-
Oh my god .. heavens forbid .. Aragorn would have to give him a manacure .. LOL!
What if Grima loved Eomer? ???
-
then he would've been heart deepley when eomer strangled him
what if the whole trilogy was one big rap?
-
Then it would be perfect for people to write about! :P ::)
What if the "one ring" was a fake? :o
-
i do believe that has already been done...but what da heck ;D
Then Frodo would'a been rewwie peed off :P :-[
What if Legolas was married? (all those poor fan girls ;))
-
He would have to paint his wifes nails aswell as his own LOL!!!
What if there was no Lord of the Rings? :o
-
then it would have to be called frodo of the rings who has to destroy a ring for no reason at all :-\
what if frodo couldnt take the ring off?
-
He'd have an Evil Finger for his whole life, and Gollum would be equally annoyed when he couldn't get the Ring off Frodo's bitten-off finger.. ::)
What if Sauron didn't have an army of orcs or uruks, but he had an army of.. Harry Potter fanatics? :o
-
then they'd all be in deep trouble, but eventualy they'd stop and cry for sirius blacks death
what if sting was actually a lightsaber? :o :P
-
Then Frodo would most porbably accidentally vwing his head off while trying to wield it.. ::)
What if Sting didn't glow blue when orcs were near, but made a voice recording like the lady from 118 247 saying "Orcs are near. The number you require is 999. No wait, Middle Earth doesn't have phones. Never mind, then.
-
then the orcs will be at a distinct disadvantage, cos they'd know that frodo didnt have a phone
what if sam was secrelty sauron?
-
Don't you mean advantage? ^-^
If Sam was secretly Sauron, then Sauron would've won the WOTR and for his Ring back before anyone had the chance to realise the Ring was evil.. ::)
WHAT IF! They had tricycles instead of horses? :-[ :o
-
(yeh i ws trying to catch you out ::))
then it would take ages to get anywhere
what if theoden didnt die?
-
Sure you were... ::) *prod*:P Oh that prodding fly is back... ;)
Then Théoden would be able to fight on and Éowyn probably wouldn't fight the Witchy because she wouldn't need to avenge Théoden. So Witchy would live on and then kill Théoden, then Éowyn will have vengeance and Witchy will die.
So basically nothing will happen :)
-
(the name is witch king)::)
you need to post a 'what if?' and dont say you were trying to catch me out
-
Oh yeah :o Whoopsie... :-[
[size=10]WHAT IF! [/size] uhm.... *thinks hard* Mordor was happy-clappy grassy fields with cute bunny-wunnies and fluffy kittens and rainbows?
-
then nobody would read or watch or even think about lotr
what if morgoth returned to be on the 'good' side
-
Then Sauron would not be defated, he would be enslaved by The Morgue 8) ;)
Whatto iffo The Witch King was actually The Witch Queen? :o
-
then she would be so goddammed sexy everyone would be after her
what if witch king wasn't cool? :o
-
Then would that make him hot? :o ::)
what if frodo was actually a girl? ::)
-
Then he would have to have Sam do his hair in the morning!
What is Gollum hell in love with Sauron?
-
then that would suck because he wouldn't have taken Frodo to destroy the ring, he would've just taken it and killed the hobbits
What if Sam was a hairdresser instead of a gardener?
-
then every ones hair would look like a plant ::)
what if pippin was a wizard :-\
-
Then he could've used his magic to get back at Gandalf for calling a fool ::)
What if the Ring Wraiths had to ride on big fluffy bunnies ;D
-
*is not amused by the amount of people disrespecting wraiths* >:(
then the coolness of the nazgul (witch king especially) would eventually make the fluffy bunnies look really cool and fierce
what if everyone realised the superiority of ring wraiths? :o
-
aww..im not disrespecting ring-wraiths ;D mr bunny...but heh heh :-[
Then we all would be in trouble, Cause don't we all have superiority issues?! ;D
What if Sam was a genious?
-
:o thats it *slap*
then he would have been able to destroy the ring by himself
what if witch king was the next dark lord (its only a matter of time) ::)
-
Then he would be really powerfull, being able to come back from the dead and all :P
What if the wraiths wore pink
-
alright! ;D thats enough...
then they'd be in style...because pink is really in this fall! ;) (not that i would know on account i only wear black :-\) heh heh :-X :)
What if Melkor came back? (muahahaha)
-
Then he would be able to stay in Mordor and watch over the precedures etc( :P) while Sauron plagued Frodo, Sam and the rest of the fellowship.
what if Galadriel knocked out Legolas, disguised herself as him and went with the fellowship, leaving poor Legolas to be Celeborn's wife? (<i'm having one of those days!)
-
(wow...ummm)
Then Legolas would be in deep caka...because Celeborn would soon find out!
What if Celeborn needed glasses, and couldn't tell the difference? :-\ ::) ;D
-
[color=006666]I did not get the 'and couldn't tell part'.
But then I shold have to say (having glasses myself) .. you should have gone to Specsavers!
What if there was no Mount Doom to destroy the Ring in (use your imagination on this one ..)[/color]
-
hhmmm...ill try 8)
Then they would have to make a lava pit, dress somebody up as Sauron, and try to fool the ring into melting :-\ :-[ :P ::) ;D (ok..i really don't have a clue ::))
What if the ring couldn't be fooled? :P :-[
-
[color=006666]Oh god please somebody help me answer this one .. anyone?
Erm, then we would have to make it drink a lot of naughty drinks so that it would be seeing double, LOL!
What if there was a great allience between Gandalf and Sauron?[/color]
-
then we'd all be screwed ;D
What if Sauron was actually a daisy-picking-little-girl?
-
then Frodo would die laughing when he saw him and Sauron would giggle and pick up the ring.....*da da daaaaaa*
what would happen if Gimli was a 6ft basket ball player?
-
[color=006666]I see where you got that one from Morliana, LOL
Then he would be able to bounce the Ring to Mount Doom safely, LOL! Just picture it ..
What it was halloween when the Fellowship was at Rivendell?[/color]
-
there would have been one hell of a fancy dress party!!! lol *pictures gimli in a pumkin costume*
::)
What if the river hadnt came when arwen did her whole
""Arwen: NÎn o Chithaeglir, lasto beth daer; Rimmo nÎn Bruinen dan in Ulaer! NÎn o Chithaeglir, lasto beth daer,
Rimmo nÎn Bruinen dan in Ulaer!
[Waters of the Misty Mountains listen to the great word: flow waters of Loudwater against the Ringwraiths!]""
(http://www.legomirk.com/lotrscript2001/cap156.jpg)
thing?
-
complex :P
Then she would have stamped her feet, pulled her pigtails and thrown Frodo to the Ringwraiths in her frustration :o
what if Frodo wasn't revived by Arwen?
-
He would have died and turned into a ring wrath thingy. hopped onto one of them nasty dragon lookin things and gave the ring back to the dark lord sticking his twos up at the rest of the fellowship :P
What happens if gandalf had walked away when Bilbo told whoever was at the door to sod off (at the beginning of FOTR movie)????
-
Not much would've changed. Gandalf STILL would've come back for Bilbo's party and the story would've gone forward as usual.
What if.... the Fellowship had somehow managed to cross the Caradhras pass, thus never having had to go through Moria?
-
Gandalf wouldn't be white, and he wouldn't have let Frodo run off by himself with Sam.
What if Frodo had killed Gollum with Sting the night he attacked them?
-
Then they would not have found there way to mount doom
What would have happened if bilbo wouldnt have left the ring to frodo?
-
Then there would be one hell of an old hobbit in Rivendell....and Sauron would need eye drops ;D
What if Legolas wore pink? 8)(never mind.... ::) :P)
-
Then he would get more laughs than now :o
what if Gimli ran off with Eowyn?
-
Then eoywn would not get a change to go with faramir.
What if froda had been killed by the orcs in return of te king?
-
Then we would all be screwed..and the ring would be in the filthy hands of Gorbar or Shagrat....most likely they would think it too shiny to take to Sauron ;)
What if: Sam hadn't come back to Frodo's aid?
-
Then most likely, Shelob would have eaten Frodo, thrown away the bones, and empty clothes and then Gollum would have took the Ring.....blah blah= destruction of Arda.
what if Sauron captured the Ring, then decided to restore Arda and join it with Valinor?
-
I can see it now....Sauron: "Ooo..Ooo..Can Melkor come play too?" ;D
What if: Gandalf was secretly evil? ::)
-
the frodo wud have probably died, sam too, the whole fellowship
-
[color=006666]Pssst, you are suppost to post a 'What if' in every post![/color]
-
i'll do it:
what if Orc overan Lorien whilst the Fellowship are there?
-
[color=006666]Then it would look like 'meats back on the menu boys ..'
What if there was a huge rubber duck instead of Mount Doom?[/color]
-
Then Sam and Frodo wouldn't be able to get to the cracks of doom due to laughing!
what if Galadriel was the bearded lady in an elven circus?
-
Then Legolas would fall off the trapeze laughing and Celeborn may go off her slightly, then there'd be a big lothlorien divorce scandal.
What if Gollum got frodo drunk and frodo gave the ring to sam?
-
Then there would be one more entoxicated hobbit in the world, and one more, I fear, "bearer"
What if...: Legolas was ugly? ;D lmao ::) :P
-
Then i wouldnt have girls screamin 'OORLANDOOOOOOOOOOOOOOOO' next to me in the cinema. sheesh.
What if arwen would have died in ROTK?
-
Then Middle earth would have been a better place..and there would have been a blonde on the throne of gondor...lol, laura
What if Eowyn and Aragorn had married? ::) ;D
-
Then eowyn woldnt have fallen in love with faramir.
It would be so tradgic.
What if aragorn would have died?
-
Arwen would have died of heartbreak, probably the fellowship would have lost heart and surrendered,yet Frodo would reach Mt. Doom and the ring would still be destroyed.
what if the Ring was chocolate?
-
[color=006666]Then I would have eaten it long ago :P.
What if Gondor had a pink tree?[/color]
-
Then gondorians would have very girly flags and probably would have had a revolution and there'd be a communist government and Aragorn wouldn't have been able to take the throne.
What if treebeard had secretly been evil and eaten merry and pippin?
-
then they would have to chop there way out, erm do trees have digestive systems? :-\
what if pippin was actualy evil and ate merry? :-\
-
Then he would follow Frodo and Sam and also eat them.
What if Legolas had had an affair with Arwen?
-
Then Aragorn would have killed Legolas.
What if legolas and gimli would have been secratly gay?
-
ewwww*barfs* that is gross :( :-X
Then they would have stayed behind in Frodo's bedroom in Gondor when everyone else left :( :o
What if Arwen and Legolas kept up the affair? :P :-[
-
[color=006666]What affair what are you talking about? :-[ :-X :-[
Then Aragorn could have gone with my little Eowyn, and she would have got the man that she deserved and also Arwen could have gone to the Undying Lands because after the War of the Ring Legolas would have followed!
What if there was no Undying Lands to go to?
Linking back the the answer above, ^.[/color]
-
[color=330066]Then Middle-Earth would still be inhabited by elves and Arwen wouldn't have to worry about dying!!!!
what if Elrond was ambushed and killed on his way to Aragorn with Anduril? :'([/color]
-
hw wud die and anduil wudnt get to aragorn
what if the king of the dead re-broke his oath?
-
Then they wouldnt have won the battle, and they all would have died, and frodo and sam probably.
What would have happened if aragorn would have fallen in love with eowyn?
-
Then Arwen would have became a motral for nothing.
What if aragorn would have died when he fell of the cliff?
-
Then Arwen would have gotten Legolas, and Eowyn would've ruled Rohan with a mighty, yet single hand ;)
What if Theoden hadn't died? 8)
-
[color=330066]Then he would return to Rohan, rebuild his reputation, perhaps rule for a few more years then die naturally and pass his power to Eomer.
what if Treebeard had stepped on Merry when he was chasing him?[/color]
-
Pippin would have been very, very sad :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'( :'(
What would happen if Saruman had bred another kind of orc more powerful than the Uruk-Hai?
-
Then it would have been more of a challenge for the Fellowship and the peoples of Middle-earth to defeat, although we would still have won.
I mean they .. :-[
What if Grima had great knowledge of the palantir and ow to work it?
-
Then Middle Earth would have been in a WHOLE lot of trouble! (Sorry, not very original answer!!)
What if Legolas fell in love with Gollum?
(Sorry, really bad question too!)
-
Then Gollum would have been able to say: "My precious(es)"
What if the Palantir was fake?
-
;Dthey could have sold it on eBay for a profit...
what if tony blair was in aragorns place?
*apocalypse, i know* :(
Elvurith***
-
Then everyone would leave Gondor!
What if Legolas messed up his hair?
-
[color=330066]Then Middle-Earth would pay......severley............... >:( *cackles*
what if Gimli blinded himself with a shard from his ax when he hit the One Ring?[/color]
-
Well I have always wondered what he would have looked like with a glass eye!
LOL!
I can just picture it now!
What if the trees at Lothlorien were only 3 meters high .. ??
-
then lorien would look so wonderfull would it? it would look a bit rubbish to be honest! lol
what is the palatir wasnt connected up to sauron, but to Gandalf?
-
Then Saruman would be talking to Gandalf without knowing it and all of his plans would have gone to waste!
What if it was all a giant game of snakes & ladders?
-
? :-\ ??? erm........ the fellowship obviously got more ladders tan they did snakes! and won the game! yey! :P
what if gandalf hadnt fell in moria and never got to come back as gandalf the white?
-
Then he would have never have been as powerful as he is now and would not have been able to deflect the Witchking and certain things like that etc ..
What if the world of Middle-earth was already in the Second Lands of Darkness?
-
[color=330066]Then the quest would be harder because evil would be more prosperous and well, evil :P
what happens if Glorfindel(going from the books here) was ambushed by Nazgul on his way to Aragorn and the hobbits?[/color]
-
Then Frodo would've fallen into Darkness.
What if Gandalf had got the ring?
-
[color=330066]Then he would try to use it for good but eventually fall to its evil and become the greatest dark power in Arda ;D
what if Merry died in the Pelennor Fields?[/color]
-
Then everyone would be deeply saddened to lose another member of the fellowship :'( (after Boromir) especially Pippin.
What if Frodo had fallen into the fires of Mount Doom?
-
then i would've cried for weeks and weeks. And sam would've jumped in as well!!
What if....Sam had drowned at the end of FOTR?
-
[color=330066]Then Frodo may have destroyed the Ring, but it would have been unlikely because he would have probably given up out of sorrow.
what if Morgoth was still in power instead of Sauron?[/color]
-
Then it'd be the same, they'd just have a worse ring and a different place to chuck it.
What if Radaghast hadn't got to Gandalf in time?
-
I don't want to turn into a English Grammer expert, but my name is Radagast, ;) .
Erm, I suppose that he would have got there in time but even if he didn't then I guess that he would have had to have fly to the top of Orthanc on the Lord of the Eagles and resque Gandalf himself!
What if the Dead Marshes was alive? :-\ ..
-
then middle earth would eventually become crowded with zombies :o
what if gollum was a girl?
-
Then he would have to be carried through the Dea Marshes, and also he would play Barbies with She-Lob!!!
What if there was pink and yellow clouds in Middle-earth?!
-
Everyone would be hiding in a cave except Legolas who would be prancing about at the front
What if the uruk-hai could stand daylight and couldn't stand it when it was night?
-
Then all of the battles would have been in the day time, and they would have had to have been wearing sun-tan lotion for those hot days!
What if the Elves were monkeys?
-
There would be an angry mob of Orlando Bloom fangirls on here and we'ed all be doooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooomed
What if Elves did get on with dwarves?
-
Then they would've slaughtered Sauron ages ago.... Oh wait, they already did.... :P
-
Galaril? You forgot a what if :( Ne' mind, I'll go in your place :)
what if Smaug had killed Bilbo in Erebor?
-
Then Frodo wouldn't have gone to live with him and he would have been forgotten about by everyone.
What if Thorin han't died in the Hobbit?
-
Erm...well Bilbo wouldn't have been put through the grief, he would have been visited a lot by Thorin and quite possibly we would have seen Thorin at Bilbo's 111st birthday.
What if The Battle of Five armies had been turned to the Orc's favour?(bilbo still lives)
-
As in everyone bar Bilbo and Gandalf dies? The orcs get the gold.
What if Gollum went skiing down the misty mountains?
-
Then we'd have a lot of hysterical migrating geese ;D
What if Legolas and Gimli didn't become friends?
-
then we would have heard alot more funny slagging off jokes! ;D :P
what if rosie got married to someone else when sam was away? :'(
-
Then Sam would be heartbroken :'( Poor Sam :'(
What if Gandalf shrunk to only three-foot tall?
-
then he'd have to ride a pony, could wear his hat instead of coat and would trip over his beard all the time or could use it as a blanket.
What if... Smeagol didnt take the ring from deagol, so that deagol kept it?
-
As before, execept from the fact that we wouldn't have the stupidly great voice from Serkis. ;D
What if Frodo had fallen into Mt Doom?
-
Then those poor eagles would only have had to carry one little hobbit away.
Wot if sam had kept the ring at cirith ungol
-
Eagles wouldn't have any Hobbits to fly away :'
What if that "thing" for a King hadn't killed Theoden?
-
Eagles wouldn't have any Hobbits to fly away :'
What if that "thing" for a King hadn't killed Theoden?
Do you mean when Saruman used Grima to corrupt Theoden? :8o
-
Nope i think she means Witch king, right? ???
-
Okay a little confusion here, Galaril would you be so kind as to post another question?
-
Possibly some time this year, ;) , only 6 more days ..
-
Bloody Hell! Okay, I'll post something.
(sorry to get peeved, I'm tired ???)
What if Frodo had left the Ring with Tom Bombadil?
-
Then one of the beasts that he tames would have got its hands on the Ringsnand it would have been corrupted.
What if Galadriel's mirror had broken and Frodo didn't see the Shire?
-
Then he perhaps wouldn't have left the Fellowship and what a chain reaction that would have caused!*Phew* my brain hurts just thinking about it! :P
What if Aragorn had gone to the Paths of the Dead without Gimli and Legolas?
-
then i dont think much would have changed, i mean , it was aragorn who got the army to come and fight, them two just tagged along! lol! ::)
what if denethor hadnt tried to burn faramir, and there fore didnt die himself?
-
Probably would've reeked havoc. Again.
What if Arwen and Aragorn never would've met?
-
Then...Arwen would not have convinced Elrond to make Anduril, Aragorn couldn't make the death fight for him which would lead to the fact that they had lost the war :-\
What if Gandalf hadn't been able to escape from Orthanc?
-
Then who knows what Saruman would have done .. >:( .
What if Lothlorien was full of chocolate trees?
-
then there'd probably be a hell of alot of fat elves! lol ::) :P
what if the horses in Rohan where actually rocking horses? (dont ask! lol)
-
Then the Ride of the Rohirrim would have been a bunch of men on rocking horses trying to move but just falling over .. :-\
What if there were plants which allowed you to jump high into the air and see what was happening for miles around?
-
[color=8b1a1a]Then I wouldn't be here much longer :P Bouncy plants! Oooo!
What if Merry was englufed by Old Man Willow?[/color]
-
Then theree would be about 3 different Dark Lords walking around and they'd probably be constantly plotting eah other's demise and also all trying to conquer Middle-earth at the same time. Gandalf would have to work vey hard! :P
you mean 4/5. Bilbo, Sauron, Frodo and Gollum and maybe Deagol
What if Isildur hadn't been killed?
-
Zen smeagol wouldnt have the ring and hed still b a nice hobbit
What if legolas really was gay?
-
then he wudnt have agreed to use his bow and arrow for fear of breaking a nail...!
what happens if saruman had decided to not be on saurons side?
-
[color=deb887]Then he could have used the Uruk-Hai to a better use, lets say aiding the fellowship against orcs etc.
what if Grima had alloped with Éowyn? :o[/color]
-
Then eowyn wouldnt marry faramir and that :-\
What if elrond couldnt see into ze future?
-
[color=deb887]Then he probably wouldn´t have been able to warn Arwen of what was to come if she gave up her mortality ???
what if Helm´s Deep had held fully against the Uruk-Hai?[/color]
-
Then the fight there would have been a picece of cake and Haldir would have survived, ;) .
What if, Aiwendil would have helped in the War of the Ring?
-
Wouldnt make a diffrence cos they wud still win with the dead people
What if Gandalf was really a woman?
-
Wouldn't make a difference because Istari are age and genderless anyway.
What if the Entmot hat taken few years?
-
[color=deb887]Merry and Pippin would have mutated and done Saruman over on their own ;D :P
what if the WitchKing had decided to keep Theoden and Éowyn as pets?[/color]
-
Then he would have probably forgotten to feed them and theyd die ::) :P
What if treebeard was evil?
-
Then Merry and Pippin would have made another lovely ingredient to ent draught :o
What if the elves suddenly discovered that sailing to the valar actually meant sailing to the north pole to work for Santa? :8o
-
[color=deb887]Then they´d protest for less obsene costumes :P
what if the Nagul rode reindeer and sung carols till you went crazy? ;D[/color]
-
You'd want to kill youself!
What if Legolas was ugly? :o
-
Well then i guess no one would ever marry him!
What if Sauron had found Pippin and found out he didn't have his ring? ::)
-
[color=deb887]Then he would have most likely kk-killed Pippin in a most horrendous and torturous way :'( :'( :'( >( >( >(
what if Merry drowned when the Uruk´s gave him his ´medicine´?[/color]
-
Then pippin would ask some 'medicine' too because he wouldnt see any point of living without merry :ph34r: :'( :'( :ph34r:
What if the Witch King would have killed Gandalf when he broke his staff?
-
Then Pippin would have killed the Witch King, since he is no man... ;)
What if Gollum hadn't bitten off Frodo's finger and fallen into the lava?
-
[color=cd853f]Well a whole host of Nazgûl would have stormed the Cracks of Doom and slaughtered Frodo and Sam(maybe Gollum too) and returned the Ring to Sauron....dum dum duuuuuummmm :o
what if Frodo was 6 feet tall?
(random I know ::))[/color]
-
Arwen would love him and he would of killed many goblins.:P
What would of happend if Uruk-hai loved plants
-
The would be so careful not to destroy any that they would have been to late for every battle.
What if Saruman had actually helped the Fellowship?
-
Then everyone would have lived happily ever after (except Sauron) ::)
What if Treebeard had accidentally squished Merry and Pippin?
-
Then they wudve died and then the trees wouldnt have kicked saurons ass
What if sauron wudve killed gandalf
-
Then Gandalf would no longer be part of the fellowship! Duh!
What if Deagol had kept the ring and smeagol never killed him for it?
-
[color=cd853f]Then we would have ourselves a big-nosed, and far less adorable Gollumy thingy >( :'( :-\
what if Rosie didn't want to marry Sam and ran of with Ted Sandyman? ;)[/color]
-
then i would have married sam and made frodo take us to the havens so he wouldnt have been so sad...
What would have happened if Tom Bombadil joined the quest?
-
Everyone would have commited suicide before the second book because of those riddles :P
What would have happened if Boromir had got the ring of Frodo?
-
Then he would probably taken it home to Gondor, if he would have made it back home that is and given it to his mad father, >( who would have (not in so many words said) 'Oh look Sauron I have the Ring - I'm a t*** .. come and get it! :P
What if Arwen had a fight with Éowyn .. naked :P :P :P[/i][/b][/color][/font]
-
What if Arwen had a fight with Éowyn .. naked :P :P :P
Aiwendil you are one strange puppy!
By "naked" I assume you also mean unarmed? If that be the case, this duel, like most unarmed cat-fights, would end in a TKO (girls never back down).. but there'd not be much productivity out of any of the other characters who witnessed the fight.
<hr>
What'd happen if Pippin had decided to go with Frodo rather than Sam?
-
Then Pippen would have been eaten by Shealob and the orks would have got the ring and then given it to saruon, so middel earth would have been distroyed :'(
What would happen if Frodo died and Sam was left with the ring.
-
Sam would have dropped it in his Potato stew. And Sauron would still be causing havoc!
What if Sam didnt come with Frodo and stayed with the rest?
-
I suppose the answer to that question would depend upon what time period you were talking about. :-\ :-\ :-\
What if - Lady Galadriel's mirror was broken and Frodo & Sam saw a wrong vision?
-
Then I guess that frodo and sam would have continued with aragorn and the fellowship and they would never depart and arrive to mordor together.
What if The Uruk-Hai would have caught Frodo and brought him back to Isengard? ??? :(
-
Then saruman would have got the ring and then be processed by it and they would have ended up in the hands of Sauron.
What would happen if Rohan did not answer to the beacons of Gondor
-
then all would have been lost, because the army of Gondor would have had no way of defeating Sauron...
what would happen if Gandalf had looked into the palantir instead of Pippin?
-
Then Gandalf would have died. if you remember, Gandalf had his back turned during the siege of Gondor, when an Orc ran at him. It would have killed him if Pippin wasn't there to stab him. If Gandalf looked into the Palantir, he would have no reason to bring Pippin.
What if Gandalf had never made aquaintance with Gwaihir the Windlord, and all the other eagles on his adventures with Bilbo?
-
Then I guess that he'd still be stuck in the trees with the Wargs below them in the forest - The Hobbit, :P.
What if - There was no sunlight in Middle-earth?
-
then it would be very very dark n the stars would be lyk street lights in th sky.... ::)
wot happens if gandalf got turned into gandalf the pink instead of the white??? :wub:
-
He would have needed a new staff to match his outfit, :P.
What is Mumakil we're baby frogs?
-
[color=deb887]Awwwwww!!!!! Baby froglings :laugh: :wub: I think I'm in love!!! ;D
*ahem* anyway, then the Rohirrim would have dismounted and gone over to pet them making broody squeely noises, and Eowyn would have adopted one ;D :-\
what if Merry had been crushed by the Mumakil?[/color]
-
pippin would ahve topped himself.......... ???
wot if elves were obese??? :P
-
Then Legolas would not have been able to walk on the snow at Caradhras, and it would mean they'd have to have eaten a LOT of lembas bread!
What if Sam had been stung by Shelob, not Frodo?...
-
Frodo would have left him behind, :P.
What if Aragorn was caught smooching Éowyn? :-*
-
Caught by whom?... Then he would have been threatened with, "Ha ha! Aragorn has a girlfriend!" etc.
What if Fell Beasts didn't exist?
-
Then they'd probably have "dark" beasts, whipped dragons, or helicopters of some kind
What if hobbits were tall?
-
Then there's no way so many people would find them cute ::)
what if hobbit holes were actually high-rise office blocks???
-
Then there would be alot of floor as hobbits are tiny.
What If Gandalf didn't get sent back after dying??
-
Then Sauron would have come back into power and whatnots... and all hope would be lost... life would end on middle earth I tell you.... it would be a total tragedy!!!! :( lol
Would would happen if Gollum was a ladie's man??
-
(and who says he isnt?!?!?) wel then, sam (coz we all kno sams a bit too in touch with his feminine side) would hav fallen for him, n they would hav taken the ring from frodo and ruled middle earth as wierd lovers, and have v.ugly odd luking children.
wot if boromir hadnt died saving merry n pippin?
-
lol!!! :laugh:
um.... they would ahve been taken away just like they were because the orcs didn't want to kill them
what would ahve happened if Bilbo had kept the ring?
-
then he wud have turned in2 a freak a leek, lukin lyk gollum, who would have hated him n they would have constantly fought over th ring until th nazgul found them n sauron took over m.e etc.
what happens if when gimli tried to break th ring (with his axe in rivendel) n the ring split in2 2...and there were 2 rings that had 2 b destroyed???
-
Then most likely, Elrond would have devised 2 fellowships to take either ring to Mordor. Either that or they'dbe stuffed ::) ;)
What if Sharky had marred the Shire beyond fixing, and there was nothing Samwise could do, even with his Mallorn seed and earth taken from Lothlorién? ???
-
then there would be very few hobbits left in the world, they would have been thought of as "endangered species" and therefore would have been killed by hunters for their...feet hair...how odd.
what if middle earth had its own underground tube service..???
-
then it would be full of orcs and spiders! and very dangerous!
What if hobbits were 6ft tall and not 4tf ??? would they have been much use at destroying the Ring ???
-
Well I don't think that it should have made any difference, the courage of the Hobbits was needed regardless of their size.
What happens if the Ents could talk but not move?
-
Then everyone would be totally deafened as they shouted out abuse at passersby etc!
What happens if there was no dam to break besides Isengard ?
-
Well then that tree which was on fire (which I nicknamed 'My main man SKINNY!') would have been burning for quite a while... :dry:
What if Gandalf had told Frodo what Bilbo was up to there and then?
-
Frodo might not have started the quest.
What if Beregrond had not slain the men in Minas Tirith?
-
Faramir could have died I presume.
What if the fellowship had not taken southward course from Imladris, but first tried the High Pass of Rivendell over the Misty Mountains?
-
It would of taken alot longer :laugh:
what if Bilbo Baggins had never killed his best friend for the ring?
Bhaal >:(
-
what if Bilbo Baggins had never killed his best friend for the ring?
Whom did he kill?
-
*thinks*
oops sorry i got confuse :'(
i ment
what if Smegal had never killed his best friend for the ring?
sorry my bad :(
Bhaal >:(
-
His friend would have killed Smeagol ::)
What if Gandalf had taken the ring from Frodo?
-
Then Gandalf would of been possessed by the ring, and used his powers to bring destruction to middle earth. :)
What if Arragon had died then the wrag had knocked him and his hoarse off of the cliff?
Bhaal >:(
-
Then Arwen would be all 'Boo hoo oh no'
Elrond would be 'Haha told you so, now go and get on that boat!'
Theoden would be like 'OOoooohhhhh deeeeaaaar' As an Uruk killed him
And Legolas would start crying because his hair would probably get messed up as he fought for his life at Helms Deep
... Not to mention the fact they'd probably LOSE at Helms Deep... LOSERS!
What if Eomer had not come back to fight at Helms Deep?
-
Then Aragorn and Theoden would have died on their final charge out through the gates, with no back up to save them.
What if Gandalf had given the ring mission to a person of another race, rather than to a hobbit?
-
Well everyone would have all met their dooooooooooooooooooooooooooom, the way of which would depend on the race ::) :D
(http://www.bronzecannon.com/Coins/Cobs1%20009.jpg)
-
What if Saruman had messed up and the Uruk Hai were actually hobbit-sized ???
-
hehehe oooh, the Hobbits could have taken them on and beaten them :laugh: :laugh:
alternatively .... what if someof the lady Hobbits fancied some of them and they you know... produced offspring! :8o :8o a disturbing thought :-\ :rofl:
-
Uruk Hai with big hairy feet!!!! hahahha
What if Mordor were on in the middle of the Misty Mountains.... how would the battle have turned out ?
-
1: the dwarfs would of hard a huge advantage (if there were any left)
or
2: they would of had to bring ROCKY in :P
What if
sam was a woman?
Bhaal >:(